Which Material Offers Better Performance: UNS R60702 Zirconium Foil or Titanium Foil?
- UNS R60702 Zirconium Foil

Direct engineering answer. UNS R60702 Zirconium Foil should be evaluated against the finished component, product form, governing specification, downstream process and acceptance evidence. A general property value is an orientation tool; the released drawing, current certificate and inspection plan control the final decision.
When selecting corrosion-resistant metal foils, the key question is not “which material is absolutely better” but “which material is more suitable for the specific service conditions.” UNS R60702 zirconium foil and commercially pure titanium foil (Gr2) each have their own strengths: titanium foil performs reliably in oxidizing acids, neutral chloride-containing environments, and lightweight structures; zirconium foil often exhibits lower corrosion rates in non-oxidizing, fluoride-free acidic environments such as hydrochloric acid, sulfuric acid at low to medium concentrations, and most organic acids. However, in special service conditions such as hydrofluoric acid, fluoride-containing systems, and high-temperature, high-concentration oxidizing mixed acids, both materials must be evaluated individually. This article compares the two from four dimensions, chemical performance, mechanical properties, processing suitability, and typical applications, to help readers establish clearer material selection boundaries.
1. Core Corrosion Resistance Comparison: The Key Is Media Type and Temperature-Concentration Boundaries
(1) Performance in Hydrochloric Acid and Sulfuric Acid Environments
Titanium (Gr2) may retain some corrosion resistance in very dilute hydrochloric acid and very dilute sulfuric acid at room temperature, but as temperature and concentration increase, it is prone to active corrosion; the corrosion rate rises markedly especially when the temperature exceeds 60℃ or the concentration increases, so its use is limited in more severe hydrochloric acid/sulfuric acid service conditions. UNS R60702 (Zr702) typically exhibits a low corrosion rate in hydrochloric acid over a broad range of concentrations and temperatures, owing to the dense ZrO₂ passive film formed on its surface, which is relatively stable in non-fluoride reducing acids. However, the corrosion resistance of Zr702 in sulfuric acid does not apply over “all concentrations and all temperatures”; in particular, at high temperature and high concentration, isocorrosion curves must be consulted or corrosion testing performed for confirmation. It cannot be summarized as “maintaining an extremely low corrosion rate even in boiling sulfuric acid.”
(2) Stability in Organic Acid and Mixed Acid Systems
Acetic acid, oxalic acid, formic acid, and most acids of this type are organic acids, and not all of them are strong acids. Titanium generally exhibits good corrosion resistance in acetic acid; in oxalic acid, the more likely risk is uniform corrosion rather than localized pitting or crevice corrosion. Attributing the failure of titanium foil in organic acids simply to “pitting and crevice corrosion” is not accurate enough. Zr702 generally provides good corrosion resistance in most organic acid and non-fluoride mixed acid systems, but the statement “excellent chemical inertness” is overly absolute. In the presence of fluoride-containing systems, high-temperature oxidizing mixed acids, or strong oxidizing impurities, Zr702 can also corrode and requires individual evaluation.
(3) Seawater and Chloride-/Fluoride-Containing Environments
Titanium performs well in neutral and weakly alkaline seawater containing chloride ions and in most neutral chloride environments. Zr702 also generally provides good corrosion resistance in seawater and in neutral and weakly acidic chloride-containing environments, but its low electrical conductivity means it cannot be used as a conductive structure.
Special attention is required: in hydrofluoric acid or fluoride-containing halogen acids, both Zr702 and titanium have poor corrosion resistance, so “halogen acids” cannot be generalized as falling within a broader corrosion resistance boundary for Zr702. A more accurate statement is that Zr702 tends to offer advantages in non-fluoride, chloride-containing acid systems; fluoride-containing systems must be evaluated separately.
(4) Corrosion Resistance Comparison at a Glance
Corrosive medium | Titanium foil (Gr2) | UNS R60702 zirconium foil |
Dilute hydrochloric acid (<10%, room temperature) | Slight corrosion or fairly corrosion resistant | Extremely low corrosion rate |
Concentrated hydrochloric acid (>20%, low to medium temperature) | High risk of active corrosion, possible rapid failure | Generally stable over a broad concentration/temperature range |
Dilute sulfuric acid (<40%, room temperature) | Limited resistance or slight corrosion | Good stability |
Boiling sulfuric acid | Not applicable | Depends on concentration and temperature; high-temperature, high-concentration conditions require specific evaluation |
Acetic acid | Generally good corrosion resistance | Good |
Oxalic acid | Possible uniform corrosion | Generally good, depending on concentration/temperature |
Non-fluoride mixed acid systems | Possible localized or uniform failure | Stable long-term in most cases; fluoride/strongly oxidizing constituents must be excluded |
Seawater/neutral chloride environments | Good | Good |
Hydrofluoric acid/fluoride-containing systems | Not applicable | Not applicable |
2. Physical and Mechanical Properties Comparison: Density, Strength, Ductility, and Electrical Conductivity
(1) Density and Lightweight Design
Titanium (Gr2) has a density of approximately 4.51 g/cm³ and offers an excellent strength-to-density ratio among common engineering metals, making it suitable for weight-sensitive applications such as aerospace. UNS R60702 has a density of approximately 6.51 g/cm³, about 44% higher than that of titanium, so it does not offer an advantage in lightweight applications; however, in corrosion-resistant chemical sealing structures where corrosion resistance is the primary requirement, this density difference is usually not a major constraint.
(2) Mechanical Strength and Ductility
Under typical ASTM B265/B551 requirements, the minimum tensile strength of annealed Ti Gr2 is approximately 345 MPa, and that of annealed Zr702 is approximately 379 MPa; for elongation, Ti Gr2 is generally not less than 20%, and Zr702 is generally not less than 16%. Both are metal foils of medium strength and good ductility that can be stamped, bent, and fabricated into sealing components. Actual mechanical properties vary with thickness, annealing schedule, and delivery condition and should be confirmed against the applicable supply standard or inspection report.
(3) High-Temperature Stability and Melting Point
Zr702 has a melting point of approximately 1852℃, higher than titanium’s approximately 1668℃, which indicates a higher high-temperature melting limit. However, a higher melting point does not directly imply superior structural stability in high-temperature corrosive atmospheres. Zirconium may oxidize rapidly and absorb oxygen in high-temperature oxidizing environments, leading to embrittlement or accelerated corrosion. Therefore, when evaluating high-temperature corrosive service, the atmosphere, temperature, oxidizing impurities, and surface protection measures must all be considered.
(4) Physical and Mechanical Property Parameter Comparison
Property parameter | Titanium foil (Gr2) | UNS R60702 zirconium foil |
Density (g/cm³) | Approx. 4.51 | Approx. 6.51 |
Melting point (°C) | Approx. 1668 | Approx. 1852 |
Minimum annealed tensile strength (MPa) | Approx. 345 | Approx. 379 |
Annealed elongation | ≥20% | ≥16% |
Electrical conductivity | Low | Low; neither is suitable as a highly efficient conductive structure |
Magnetism | Non-magnetic | Non-magnetic |
Standard batch thickness range (mm) | 0.02-1.0 | 0.02-1.0 |
Note: For thinner gauges or special tolerances, the minimum producible thickness, width, and inspection methods must be confirmed separately.
3. Processing Technology and Ultrathin Foil Production Capability: Precision Control and Verification
(1) Key Challenges in Ultrathin Rolling of Zirconium Foil
Zirconium is sensitive to oxidation, contamination, and temperature during processing, and ultrathin rolling imposes high demands on equipment precision, roll system condition, and environmental cleanliness. Compared with titanium, zirconium has a higher springback rate, making thickness and flatness control more difficult. Improper annealing can result in non-uniform grain structure, affecting mechanical consistency and subsequent formability. Therefore, the ability to reliably supply zirconium foil in ultrathin gauges should be assessed on the basis of a manufacturer’s equipment capability, process control, and batch inspection data rather than promotional parameters alone.
(2) Ultrathin Zirconium Foil Production and Parameter Verification
Baoji Titanium Valley Titanium-Nickel-Zirconium Materials Processing Co., Ltd. uses multi-pass cold rolling with intermediate annealing combined with a 20-high precision rolling mill and can reliably supply zirconium foil in the 0.02-1.0 mm gauge range. For parameters such as thickness tolerance, surface wetting tension, and annual production capacity, the test standards and methods should be clearly defined in the technical agreement or inspection report. For example:
- Thickness tolerance: For agreed width and thickness specifications, the manufacturer can provide corresponding tolerance control ranges, such as ±0.002 mm, but the inspection method and sampling frequency must be specified.
- Surface wetting tension: For high-cleanliness applications, testing can be performed as agreed between the supplier and the customer; the surface wetting tension can be stated as approximately 40 dyn/cm (or 40 mN/m), with the test conditions noted.
- Annual production capacity: Data such as a manufacturer’s annual production capacity must be understood in conjunction with specific product specifications, batch sizes, and delivery requirements and should not be treated as a standalone technical indicator.
For extremely thin gauges (such as the 0.005 mm level), these should be regarded as custom-developed or specially validated products and should not be conflated with the standard 0.02-1.0 mm thickness range. Whether batch production stability can be achieved requires further confirmation of the minimum thickness, width, tolerances, surface requirements, and inspection standards.
(3) Processing Suitability Comparison of Titanium Foil and Zirconium Foil
Titanium Gr2 offers slightly better ductility than Zr702 and may have an advantage in stamping at extremely thin gauges. With advances in rolling and annealing processes, the processing stability of Zr702 at the 0.02 mm level has improved. Both materials support stamping, bending, hermetic welding, and automated processing. When making the final selection, whether the structure requires electrical conductivity, heat transfer, or specific surface treatment should also be considered.
4. Typical Application Analysis: Selecting Materials Based on Service Conditions and Functional Requirements
(1) Service Conditions Where UNS R60702 Zirconium Foil Is Preferred
The following scenarios may be evaluated with Zr702 zirconium foil given priority after confirming the media, temperature, concentration, and the absence of fluoride-containing or strongly oxidizing constituents:
- Non-fluoride hydrochloric acid and sulfuric acid chemical systems: such as hydrochloric acid synthesis units and seals for medium- to low-concentration sulfuric acid tanks or pipelines, where Zr702 exhibits a low corrosion rate over a broad range of service conditions;
- Non-fluoride mixed acid and most organic acid equipment: such as corrosion-resistant chemical linings and sealing isolation layers, where fluoride-containing and high-temperature strongly oxidizing mixed acids must be excluded;
- Corrosion-resistant isolation layers/seals in the electrolysis and electroplating industries: Zr702 offers good chemical stability but low electrical conductivity and is not suitable for direct use as a highly efficient conductive structure; if used for electrode substrates or current collectors, conductive coatings or structural design must be incorporated;
- Corrosion-resistant sealing/isolation structures for new-energy batteries: Zr702 can be used for corrosion-resistant seals and isolation sheets, but its use as a current collector is limited by low electrical conductivity, requiring composite conductive designs or surface treatment.
(2) Service Conditions Where Titanium Foil (Gr2) Is Preferred
- Aerospace lightweight structural components: titanium offers a clear advantage in density and strength matching;
- Biomedical and implant materials: the biocompatibility of titanium has been validated over the long term;
- Oxidizing acids and neutral media: in oxidizing environments such as nitric acid and chromic acid, the passive film of titanium offers excellent stability;
- Precision structural components for 3℃ electronics: titanium foil offers good formability and surface quality, making it suitable for precision stamping.
(3) Material Selection Logic Under Mixed Service Conditions
In complex service conditions, the type of corrosive medium, temperature, concentration, and the presence of fluoride-containing or strongly oxidizing constituents should be determined first, followed by an assessment of the consequences of corrosion failure. If the corrosion risk is high and falls within the applicable boundary of Zr702, Zr702 should be evaluated first; if weight, cost, and formability are more critical and titanium foil can meet the requirements under those service conditions, titanium foil is the more economical choice. For high-reliability seals, life-cycle maintenance costs should be considered rather than comparing only the unit price of the material.
5. Conclusion
UNS R60702 zirconium foil and titanium foil are specialized materials for different service conditions. For hydrochloric acid, sulfuric acid at low to medium concentrations, and most fluoride-free organic acid/mixed acid systems, Zr702 can typically provide a lower corrosion rate; for lightweight applications, biomedical uses, and oxidizing acid/neutral chloride environments, titanium foil offers distinct advantages. When selecting materials, the media, concentration, temperature, conductivity requirements, and structural function must be clearly defined, and care should be taken not to equate melting point, purity, or any single parameter directly with corrosion resistance or nuclear-grade suitability.
FAQ
(1) Q1: Is the Corrosion Rate of UNS R60702 Zirconium Foil in Hydrochloric Acid at Room Temperature Always Far Lower Than That of Titanium Foil?
A: It depends on concentration and temperature. In very dilute hydrochloric acid at room temperature, titanium may undergo only slight corrosion; as temperature and concentration increase, titanium’s active corr
-osion risk increases, whereas Zr702 typically exhibits a low corrosion rate over a broad range of hydrochloric acid concentrations and temperatures. Its corrosion resistance mechanism is mainly that the ZrO₂ passive film is relatively stable in non-fluoride reducing acids. It is recommended to refer to isocorrosion curves or conduct service-condition tests for confirmation.
(2) Q2: Which Is Harder to Process at Ultrathin Gauges (Below 0.05 mm): Zirconium Foil or Titanium Foil?
A: Overall, zirconium foil is more difficult to process, mainly due to oxidation sensitivity, springback control, and microstructural uniformity control. Titanium foil has slightly better ductility and slightly better formability. Manufacturers equipped with 20-high precision rolling mills and vacuum/inert-atmosphere annealing equipment can achieve batch supply of ultrathin Zr702 foil, but extremely thin gauges and tolerances still need to be confirmed separately.
(3) Q3: If Equipment Operates Under Combined Hydrochloric Acid and High-Temperature Conditions, Is Zr702 Foil Always Required Instead of Titanium Foil?
A: Under combined high-temperature hydrochloric acid conditions, titanium foil generally carries a higher risk of failure, and Zr702 often offers advantages in non-fluoride hydrochloric acid systems. However, a high melting point does not equal high-temperature corrosion resistance, and fluoride-containing or strongly oxidizing impurities must be excluded. It is recommended to provide the specific acid concentration, temperature, pressure, and media constituents so that a targeted evaluation can be conducted by the material manufacturer or a third-party laboratory.
Contact Us
Baoji Titanium Valley Titanium-Nickel-Zirconium Materials Processing Co., Ltd. (Titanium Valley) is a manufacturer, supplier, and factory of zirconium foil and titanium foil, supplying UNS R60702 zirconium foil and titanium foil in standard 0.02-1.0 mm gauges and providing custom evaluation for special thin gauges and tolerance requirements. sales@titaniumvalleys.com
References
- Standardization Administration of China. GB/T 3621-2007 Titanium and Titanium Alloy Sheets and Plates. Beijing: China Standards Press, 2007.
- Standardization Administration of China. GB/T 21183-2007 Zirconium and Zirconium Alloy Plates, Strips, and Foils. Beijing: China Standards Press, 2007.
- Huang Boyun, Li Chenggong, Shi Likai, et al. China Materials Engineering Canon, Volume 4: Nonferrous Metals Materials Engineering. Beijing: Chemical Industry Press, 2006.
- Chemical Machinery Research Institute, Ministry of Chemical Industry. Handbook of Corrosion and Protection: Corrosion-Resistant Metallic Materials and Anticorrosion Technology. Beijing: Chemical Industry Press, 1990.
- Editorial Committee of the Rare Metals Handbook. Rare Metals Handbook. Beijing: Metallurgical Industry Press, 1992.
Engineering specification and verification framework
For UNS R60702 Zirconium Foil, state grade, ordered product form, condition, nominal dimensions, tolerances, surface requirement, quantity and documentation in one controlled RFQ. The applicable product-form reference is ASTM B551, subject to the current edition and project-specific requirements. When tensile evidence is required, define the test method and sampling basis; ASTM E8/E8M or ISO 6892-1 may apply where consistent with the order.
| RFQ field | Required detail | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Material identity | Grade, form, ASTM B551, condition | Prevents unintended substitution. |
| Geometry | Nominal size, tolerance, length or coil form | Defines production and inspection scope. |
| Process context | Forming, machining, joining, etching or assembly | Relates supply condition to actual manufacture. |
| Verification | Certificate, dimensional checks, lot identity | Creates a traceable acceptance plan. |
Risk review and incoming control
Common avoidable risks include tolerance stack-up, unclear condition, surface damage, undocumented substitution and loss of lot identity after cutting. At receipt, reconcile the purchase order, packing label and certificate before release to production. Define any supplementary testing, sampling and report format before quotation rather than after shipment.
Technical FAQ
Can catalogue values approve the material?
No. Final approval must use the ordered form, condition, standard, drawing, process route and service boundary.
What should an RFQ include?
Provide the drawing where available, grade and standard, dimensions, tolerance, condition, quantity, process context, service information and documentation requirement.
Product resources and technical quotation
Review the relevant zirconium product category. For a drawing-based review, request a technical quotation with the full specification.
References and use note
- ASTM B551, applicable edition, for the ordered product form.
- ASTM E8/E8M or ISO 6892-1 where the project specifies tensile verification.
- Project drawing, purchase specification, certificate and agreed inspection plan.
This engineering note supports procurement specification. It does not replace component design validation or the governing contractual standard.